top of page
Home: Welcome

We have moved to the north end of the plaza!
Call for any questions!


We Are Open To the Public Wednesday, Thursday & Friday: 10am - 5pm

Sat: 10am - 3pm

Sunday, Monday & Tuesday: By Appointment Only

We Do Not Make Same Day Appointments

BBB SEal[11520].png


542 C Route 9 Waretown NJ 08758

(609) 693-1800

We'll get back to you as soon as we can!

Home: Contact
Home: Opening Hours
British Pound Coins


In the summer of 1954, my grandfather, Joe, knew it was time for a change. Tired and sore from years of sheet metal work on the high-rise buildings of Manhattan, he decided to pursue his dream of working in numismatics. Joe opened a small coin shop on Hudson Street in Hackensack, and never looked back.

Of course, things have changed from the 1950’s. The shop has moved, from Hackensack to Bergenfield, then later to Point Pleasant and finally to Waretown. Joe passed away in 1997, but the family legacy lives on through a continued and shared passion for numismatics.

My father Matt has owned and operated Waretown Stamp & Coin in this location since 1984. Working as a philatelist and a numismatist for nearly 45 years has given my father an expertise that is second to none. When he's not at the shop, you can find Matt training Myles, his rambunctious Belgian Malinois, or ushering at Ocean Community Church. Matt also loves spending time in Jim Thorpe, Pennsylvania, where he owns an investment property. 


I joined the team full time in 2007. In my spare time, I teach yoga and forage for mushrooms in the Pine Barrens. My dear friend Rebecca joined the team in 2020, and is excited to have an opportunity to learn about the business of numismatics. 

We are proud to say our small business has fully supported three generations of our family. We consider ourselves blessed to be able to do something we love, while offering a service to the community. Thank you for taking the time to get to know us, and please let us know if you have any questions.

Bonnie Nestadt

Home: About


We buy all coins that are worth more than their face value.

Don’t know if your coins are worth more than face value? No problem!

We offer free verbal appraisals for all our customers.

When you bring your coins in to the shop, we will organize them in a way that makes sense to us, answer any questions you have, and then provide you with a verbal estimate as to their value. If the estimate is agreeable to you, you can choose to sell your coins at that time, but if not, you just take them back home.

Please give us a call if you’d like to bring in your coins for a free verbal appraisal.

Home: About
Home: About


We’re disappointed to say the stamp market is not excellent at this time. We are still purchasing some stamp collections, but as a rule we don’t like to get folks’ hopes up with stamps. With that said, the only way to know if your collection is something we would purchase is for us to see it in person.


Please give us a call if you’d like to bring in your stamps for a free verbal appraisal.



Home: About



Home: About



Home: About
bottom of page